Over at Deeper in the Game Chris Chinn has posted the following well-considered D&D v3.5 gamehacks and, of particular interest, why he’d use them (copied here so I don’t lose them). I reckon they’re well worth a try and look forward to any further suggestions. Thanks Chris
1. Character Generation
Characters get a set array of stats: 18, 16, 14, 12, 10, 8. (Thank you Mike Mearls & Iron Heroes). Now the tricky part: Roll 1d6 to randomly determine which of your 6 attributes gets the 18 score. Roll another 1d6 to determine which one gets the 8 (reroll if you get the same attribute). Assign the rest of the attribute scores as you will.
First, the set array avoids the problems you get when one person in the party is rolling with 4 18’s and the someone else has all 12’s. Though not as gimpy as older editions when you could have a bunch of stats in 4-7 range, it still sucks to be third best at everything.
Second, the randomization of your high/low score limits your optimal builds, but doesn’t break your character. It’s the fun part of randomization where you take what you get and try to make the best of it, without getting totally screwed.
2. Class Defense, modified
Unearthed Arcana has rules for Class Defense, where your heroes have a natural sort of AC, and don’t always have to be walking tanks of armor to avoid being hit.
The change here, is which classes get which class defense ranking:
A- Wizards, Sorcerers
B- Clerics, Bards, Paladins, Druids
C- Fighters, Rangers, Barbarians
D- Monks, Rogues
This jibes a lot better with my idea of fantasy, where you have room for both Fafhd and the Grey Mouser as competant combatants without having to be loaded in metal. I flip around the classes because I hate how D&D always takes the classes who are supposed to be cagey and dodgy and makes them easy to hit. Sure, they get a couple of avoidance bonuses, but between poor AC and meh HP, they’re not the heroes who dance between blades.
Like the UA rules, you either get the Class Defense bonus or your AC bonus, depending on which is better.
You get 2 HP/Armor bonus per encounter, which work like Temp HP vs. physical damage. So if you’ve got Leather and a Buckler for + 3 AC? That’s +6 hp per encounter vs. physical damage.
You also get a bonus to either a Fort or Ref save once per encounter, equal to your AC bonus, but only against physical threats armor might protect against (arrow trap? Yeah, armor helps. Snake poisoned you? Too late, good luck). Unlike normal bonuses, you can choose to apply this AFTER you’ve failed.
Under the normal UA class defense rules, the main decisions between armor or no armor is which is giving you a better bonus AND whether you need to be stealthy. Now armor provides another set of bonuses which makes it useful in a tangle.
Does this significantly change the survivability of PCs and low level play? Sure, but in ways I like. Armor isn’t the only way to avoid getting hit, but it provides enough other bonuses that you probably want to wear it. The once per encounter save makes armor able to save your bacon, over and over.
4. Pulp death rules
I’ve written about these before, but honestly, they just work for me. If your hero is knocked to -10 hp, they’re dead. If they’re at 0 or less, they do not lose hitpoints each round, but instead stabilize and regain 1 hp per hour unconscious until they wake up at 0 hitpoints.
First, it makes heroes tougher, and more likely to be captured rather than all bleed to death seconds after the combat ends. Second, it doesn’t make tough combats into a “race to heal” game which usually ends in TPKs. Finally, it lowers the amount of bookkeeping you do round to round.
Surprisingly, all I’m doing is shifting the outlook on Alignment.
Neutral means you try to help yourself, friends, family, allies, etc. Good means you go out of your way to help others, even when there is no reward involved. Evil means you go out of your way to harm others, even when there is no benefit to gain. Lawful means you support the status quo over the needs of the individual. Chaos means you support the needs of the individual over the status quo.
This keeps alignment in the game, which is used for enough effects that it’d actually be really hard to rip out, but at the same time grounds it in a way I can deal with. If you look at it, it’s really a set up for Heroquest-y/blood opera-ey type things if you want to play with it that way.
I really want to set up a reward system that better produces a certain style of D&D play- the PCs actually act as comrades, heroic things are said and undertaken, etc. It’s probably going to be a loose tie between Burning Wheel’s Artha and Shadow of Yesterday’s Keys. I also want to fiddle with magic items so they don’t become the game tilter that they currently are.